Question and answer
To what extent was the Progressive Era actually progressive?
To what extent was the Progressive Era actually progressive? The American constitution prior to the Progressives was oriented toward a local form of democracy centered in the states. [ The Senate was elected by the state legislatures, and because no law could be passed without the concurrence of the Senate, the States had a natural check against over-expansion of federal legislation or control.
Socialists had the idea of a centralized political democracy which was less than democratic because the governing agents were answerable to a greatly enlarged polity. To accomplish this, they supported the Seventeenth Amendment, stripping the states (unconstitutionally) of their representation in the national councils. (FYI: It is unconstitutional because the Constitution prohibits a State from being stripped of its representation without its consent, and most of the states in the South plus Rhode Island and Utah refused to ratify). Let me put that another way: In the Constitutional Convention of 1787, an important debate was over how many representatives were needed to represent the American people. One per 40,000 was selected, changed to 1 per 30,000 at the last minute when Washington penciled that in. This and the limitations imposed on the national councils actually increases the democracy by moving the fountainhead of legislation closer to the local level, where representatives actually represent a fewer number of people. Indeed, the states in New England were so small that a representative's constituency actually could be less than 100 people. Clearly, that is much closer to participatory democracy than 1 per 30,000, and when you consider today, much closer than the 1 per 600,000 which serves the modern Congress. Representatives actually know and live among the represented, so they truly represent. The flip side of that, of course, is that the growth and spread of capitalism created problems so geographically spread out that local legislation probably could not redress them. In that sense, one would have to acknowledge that Progressivism succeeded, but that judgment is made by us after the fact. ]
Expert answered|lpeples|Points 180|
Asked 7/27/2013 11:50:47 PM
0 Answers/Comments
Get an answer
New answers

There are no new answers.


There are no comments.

Add an answer or comment
Log in or sign up first.
Questions asked by the same visitor
To what extent was the Progressive Era actually progessive
Weegy: Answer: The year 1896 marks the approximate beginning of the Progressive Era, and reform peaked during the period before America’s entry into World War I in 1917. [ But in a larger sense, the reform impulse in America was present even in colonial times, and it continued into the modern era. Today few Americans would claim that this country provides a level playing field for all citizens and workers, or that our political system is free from corruption of one sort or another. Thus the progressive beat goes on. During the “reckless decade” of the 1890s the impulse for reform was driven by the Populist Party, which was made up of farmers, small businessmen and reform-minded leaders who were willing to confront the growing problems in the country. The situation was summarized dramatically in the Populist Party platform, issued at its convention in Omaha in 1892. ] (More)
Expert Answered
Asked 7/27/2013 11:47:38 PM
0 Answers/Comments
21,996,160 questions answered
Popular Conversations
Locate the verbal in the following sentence and identify its ...
Weegy: Check the turkey to see if it is done. Infinitive: To see; Use: Adverb. User: Locate the infinitive and ...
9/3/2015 4:37:24 PM| 4 Answers
Fishing is the leading industry in ...
9/3/2015 9:21:23 AM| 2 Answers
As a sales person for Tan's Bakery, Yolanda is paid a straight ...
Weegy: Yolanda's total gross pay is $12,741.3. It is where 5.3% of $12,100 is $641.3, then add it to $12,100, resulting ...
9/3/2015 11:43:02 AM| 2 Answers
4x3 – 3x2 + x + 3x3
Weegy: x=4
9/3/2015 12:54:05 PM| 2 Answers
Locate the complete adjective phrase and the noun modified. I heard ...
Weegy: Please indicate the sentence so I can give you the answer. Thanks! User: Locate the complete adjective phrase ...
9/3/2015 4:46:53 PM| 2 Answers
In a short story, any pronoun that indicates a person or thing spoken ...
Weegy: In a short story, any pronoun that indicates a person or thing spoken of is given in the third person. ] ...
9/3/2015 6:14:06 PM| 2 Answers
Which listening barrier is interrupting effective communication in ...
Weegy: Taylor: I just found out my dad got us tickets for the football game! Morgan: I don't watch professional sports ...
9/3/2015 8:42:13 PM| 2 Answers
Weegy Stuff
Points 138 [Total 9461]| Ratings 0| Comments 138| Invitations 0|Online
Points 102 [Total 9412]| Ratings 1| Comments 92| Invitations 0|Offline
Points 73 [Total 378]| Ratings 0| Comments 73| Invitations 0|Offline
Points 49 [Total 833]| Ratings 0| Comments 49| Invitations 0|Offline
Points 39 [Total 572]| Ratings 0| Comments 39| Invitations 0|Offline
Points 23 [Total 28]| Ratings 1| Comments 3| Invitations 1|Offline
Points 20 [Total 208]| Ratings 0| Comments 20| Invitations 0|Offline
Points 17 [Total 17]| Ratings 0| Comments 7| Invitations 1|Online
Points 10 [Total 10]| Ratings 0| Comments 0| Invitations 1|Offline
Points 9 [Total 233]| Ratings 0| Comments 9| Invitations 0|Offline
Home | Contact | Blog | About | Terms | Privacy | Social | ©2015 Purple Inc.